Ever since her husband Doug passed away three years ago right before Christmas, Lindsey can’t get into the holiday spirit. But this year, Lindsey’s 11-old daughter Hannah is pushing for a proper Christmas with all the trimmings and Lindsey relents. With the intention of having a simple Christmas this year, mother and daughter make a trip to an annual Gilford tradition – St. George’s Christmas Rummage Sale.
Hannah finds a second-hand Christmas stocking -- a little old, a little used but plenty charming – and brings it home with her. When objects inexplicably start to appear in the stocking, and just when they are needed most, Hannah is convinced it’s magic but Lindsey isn’t buying it.
Complicating life for Lindsey is Scott Terrell, the handsome, single construction designer who’s restoring the town’s gazebo for the town’s upcoming tree lighting ceremony, a project Lindsey is overseeing. There are sparks between them but she’s hesitant to truly leave her past behind and move forward. But with the help of a possibly-maybe-probably magic Christmas stocking unlocking the town’s mysteries, Lindsey finds the true meaning of the season – love that brings families together, no matter how old or new.
The movie stars Bridget Regan as Lindsey, Victor Webster as Scott, Imogen Tear as Hannah and Iris Quinn as Donna.