Premieres Saturday, November 4 at 9 PM ET/PT
on Hallmark Movies & Mysteries
Every Christmas, professional Secret Santa Tom (Sam Page) helps clients give their loved ones the perfect presents, earning him his “Mr. Christmas” nickname. Though he typically avoids working for people he knows, when his former fraternity brother Paul (Sam Guinan-Nyhart) asks him to find the perfect Christmas present for his girlfriend Jenny (Tara Holt), Tom reluctantly agrees.
Through a personality profile that Paul (partially) fills out, and through good, old-fashioned surveillance, Tom learns more about Jenny, who recently moved to Chicago with Paul after he was offered a big job. Jenny is always giving of her time – even choosing a career at a non-profit. At Paul’s behest, Tom joins Paul and Jenny for dinner to learn more about her.
At dinner, Jenny recruits Tom to help her plan a holiday event for her non-profit. Tom finds a perfect venue for the event: an estate where his former high maintenance client Victoria (Emily Peterson) lives.
The more time Tom spends with Jenny planning the event, the more he grows fond of her. He is touched by how sentimental she is when she talks about her late father and how she wishes she could hear him perform in his blues band once more. Though a spark begins to grow between the two, they are both too loyal to Paul to act on it. As there feelings grow, will that loyalty start to wane?